It's interesting how adults always frame their objectives for the betterment of the children, but their desires are just their own and forced upon the victims, the kids. I suppose some of them are realistic about their ambitions, the New Math's goal for the preparation of the next generation of scientists, regardless of how it negatively affected the children. Schools shouldn't be a political battleground, they should be a safe place for student learning. My strong opinions aside I think that conservative and progressive math have more in common than one might first assume. The goal is to prepare students for what each believes the purpose of math is in our society. Obviously they both have very different ideas of what is important in society, but both of them are trying to look out for the future of the next generation. I honestly don't think there is a correct answer between the two ideologies, math should be both conservative and progressive, it should give students both mathematical fluency and understanding, absorbing some facts and eliciting inquiry/sense-making, etc. How do we educate the public and gain their trust in our balanced mathematical teachings at school?
The public has always been something that has annoyed me, diverse opinions are important, democracy allows all voices to be heard, but how much should we really be equally valuing the opinions of those who are not educated on the subject? Do we listen to the public and look to their input when conducting experiments on astrophysics, nuclear physics, etc? No, we and they both understand that they don't have the knowledge to positively contribute to the research or projects being done, yet the public thinks they have enough knowledge on education to direct its course. How do we help the public understand that something as "simple" as teaching and education is much more complex than the layperson understands? How do we value parents' input on their children's learning while keeping their misconceptions and sometimes dogmatic opinions out of it?
I don't have the answers to these questions at the moment, and I'm not sure they'll be solved anytime soon in this hostile political climate, but I can hope that my schools and districts are able to stay out of the battlefield.
Beautiful and heartfelt writing, Eleiah!! I agree very strongly with you that adults far too often burden kids with the adults' own desires, with little thought about what the kids themselves really want. I see this especially around the search for child prodigies (in math, in music, in gymnastics, etc. etc.), for the purposes of adult bragging rights, and often to the great detriment of the kids...it's infuriating! I'm also very interested in your thoughts about whether public opinion should have such a strong influence on education systems. I think our political system is quite confused about this: on one hand, education is about how kids get introduced to the cultures and practices they are growing into, so everyone might want to have some discussion about that -- but on another hand (there may be a lot more than 2 hands here), education is a very complex undertaking, and involves many aspects of society, so it might be better to avoid sudden shifts based on poorly-informed or easily-manipulated public opinion. Important things to think about! And I really like your points about balancing a variety of approaches to help kids learn and understand.
ReplyDelete